My most recent purchase was the Rimmel exaggerate eyeliner in Sable, and, much like the reviews on its website, I am all over it.
Makes for truly B.A. eyes
Can smudge easily- definitely not a dealbreaker
Tip: I suggest the brown for a smoky eye: First cover your eyelid in light gold. Enhance the shape by a light dab of white/pale/or shimmer under the curve of your eyebrow. Next, dab on a light brown in the corners of your eyelids. Wing the eyeliner along your lid. Finish by dabbing a dark brown to blend the two in. Voila!